```html

AITA for not wanting to watch my sister change my niece’s diaper?

I adore my newborn niece and want to be the best aunt ever — but the sight (and smell) of a dirty diaper makes me physically gag. My sister thinks I’m being dramatic. Am I?

I’m 21F, and my sister (30F) just had her first baby. I’m thrilled to be an aunt and have been spending time with them since my niece came home from the hospital. It’s my first time around a newborn — I’ve been learning how to hold her, burp her, feed her, and even help soothe her. I really love being part of this new chapter for my family.

I want to help and be involved, but when it comes to diaper changes, I physically can’t handle it — and my family thinks that makes me unreliable.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

The issue started when my sister and mom kept inviting me to “watch and learn” during diaper changes so I could babysit in the future. But I’m extremely squeamish — smells, bodily fluids, even minor messes make me nauseous. The first time they asked, I tried to stay and observe, but I started gagging and had to leave the room. They laughed at first but then said I’d never be able to help properly if I couldn’t handle a diaper.

“You can’t babysit if you won’t even watch me change her,” my sister told me.

I tried explaining that I’m fine feeding, rocking, and playing with the baby — just not diaper duty. My sister said that’s not realistic because babies need changing often. The argument ended with her frustrated, saying I was being overdramatic. I genuinely felt awful, like I was failing as an aunt. But no matter how hard I try, the sight and smell of poop just trigger an immediate gag reflex I can’t control.

“I felt like a bigger baby than the actual baby.”

After reading advice online, I realized it’s okay to set boundaries. I plan to tell my sister I’ll only babysit for short periods (or not at all) until I can handle diaper changes. I still want to be supportive — just within what I can realistically manage without fainting or throwing up.

🏠 The Aftermath

My sister calmed down after a while but was still disappointed. She said she expected me to “step up” as an aunt, which made me feel guilty all over again.

I tried to explain that my reaction isn’t stubbornness — it’s an involuntary physical response. I’m not refusing to help; I’m just trying not to vomit while doing it. My mom sided with her at first but later admitted she also used to gag changing us as babies.

Now things are mostly fine, though I still sense tension whenever I visit. I’m hoping that with time, I can desensitize myself, but I’d rather build up slowly than force it and make everyone uncomfortable.

Not everyone is built for diaper duty — and that’s okay.

It’s taken a bit of humility to admit that being a great aunt doesn’t have to mean doing every single task perfectly right away.

ADVERTISEMENT

💭 Emotional Reflection

This wasn’t about being unwilling — it was about capacity. Some people can handle messy tasks with ease; others have genuine physical aversions that don’t make them bad relatives or caregivers.

Parenting and childcare are full of responsibilities that not everyone is suited for, and that’s why teamwork matters. It’s better to know your limits and communicate them than to overpromise and fail under pressure.

Reasonable people can disagree, but empathy goes both ways — between new parents learning patience and loved ones still adjusting to their own comfort zones.

---

Commenters on Reddit had mixed but understanding reactions.

Not everyone has the stomach for diaper duty — you’re fine. Just be honest about your limits.

You’re not an AH, but babysitting without being able to change diapers isn’t realistic. Boundaries are fair, though.

New moms can be stressed and sensitive — she probably just needed help and felt overwhelmed. Talk it out calmly.

Most agreed I’m not the AH, as long as I communicate clearly and don’t take on responsibilities I can’t manage. A few suggested easing into it slowly with wipes or practice dolls — baby steps, literally.

---

🌱 Final Thoughts

Being a supportive aunt doesn’t mean forcing yourself to do what makes you physically ill. Love can show up in other ways — through time, laughter, and patience.

It’s okay to say, “That’s not for me right now,” and still be part of the baby’s life. Boundaries and compassion can coexist, even in a diaper-scented world.

What do you think?
Would you push yourself to try diaper duty, or set a hard no? Share your thoughts below 👇

---

```