AITA for calling my SIL a r*cist after she compared my cooking to "making kung pao chicken"?

AITA for Calling My SIL Racist After She Said My Job Is Just “Making Kung Pao Chicken”?

I’m an Asian chef married into a family that mostly liked me—except for one sister-in-law who nitpicked my cooking and finally dropped a slur-laced put-down. I called it out, walked out, and the whole family exploded.

I’ve been with my wife ~10 years; we’re a mixed-race couple. I’m a professionally trained chef at a high-end Chinese restaurant (award-winning team, next in line for executive chef). My SIL “Sarah” is also a chef at an upscale French spot and constantly critiques me whenever we cook at my in-laws’—everything from my knife work to marinades. I keep it polite, but she never lets up. During my MIL’s birthday prep, we were behind and hustling when Sarah walked in, scoffed at my station, and started in again. I told her to stop. She laughed and said working at a Chinese place is just “making Kung Pao chicken.” The kitchen went silent; my FIL snorted; my MIL snapped at Sarah. I called Sarah a racist POS, apologized to MIL, and left with my wife.

I’m a trained chef, not your punchline. When my culture and work got mocked, I set the pan down and drew a line.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Relationship context: I usually get along with my MIL, BIL, and other SIL; my FIL and Sarah have always been chilly. Sarah and I are both trained chefs, but she treats French technique as gospel and Chinese cuisine as a joke. My wife backed me, but begged me to apologize to stop the drama. I refused; racism isn’t a “difference of opinion.”

“‘Making Kung Pao chicken at some Chinese restaurant doesn’t count.’ That was the line—and she crossed it.”

Escalation came fast: family group chats split, cousins DM’d my wife apologizing for Sarah. FIL called it “a joke but kind of true.” Then Sarah ranted at work; a coworker reported it. A cousin posted my story to Sarah’s Facebook; friends piled on. FIL left me a voicemail saying my “presence was only being tolerated” and threatened a “world of hurt” if I didn’t delete the post. My boss and team had my back when trolls tried calling my restaurant to get me fired.

“I set a boundary. She lit it on fire—and then blamed me for the smoke.”

Outcome: Sarah was demoted after her public rant and FB fallout; staff froze her out. She quit and is basically blacklisted locally (ironic twist: her place is partly owned by a Chinese investment group). My MIL heard FIL’s voicemail and—already unhappy—asked for a divorce after he refused to apologize. MIL moved in with us temporarily. I never apologized to Sarah. I did reach out through industry friends about out-of-state openings; she hasn’t apologized to me, but I won’t block her from eating if she’s willing to change.

🏠 The Aftermath

Family lines hardened; the great Facebook war scorched earth. Some relatives cut contact; there were screaming matches and even a police-adjacent incident, per MIL. My boss told callers using slurs to pound sand and doubled down on supporting me.

MIL is separating from FIL; she’s staying with us while things settle. Sarah’s job hunt is rough; word travels fast in kitchens. I didn’t want her ruined—I wanted the racism to stop.

I’m not sorry for naming what Sarah said. I am sorry it took this much collateral damage for some people to take it seriously.

Respect isn’t a garnish. If you won’t serve it, don’t be surprised when people send the plate back.

We’re rebuilding: fewer group dinners, more boundaries, and a kitchen where culture isn’t a punchline.

ADVERTISEMENT

💭 Emotional Reflection

This wasn’t a “chef vs. chef” ego fight. It was about dismissing a whole cuisine and culture as lesser—then hiding behind “it was a joke.” Gatekeeping masked as gastronomy is still prejudice.

Calling out racism isn’t the same as canceling someone. Consequences came from Sarah’s own words—first in my in-laws’ kitchen, then in hers. Growth is possible, but it starts with accountability.

Families survive hard conversations by choosing respect over denial. When that fails, boundaries do what apologies won’t.

---

Community reactions poured in like ticket orders on a Saturday rush:

“NTA. Chinese cuisine isn’t ‘less than’—it’s world-class. She insulted your work and your identity.”

“It wasn’t a joke; it was contempt. Good on MIL for backing you and setting her own boundary.”

“You don’t owe an apology for naming racism. She owes several.”

Most readers sided with OP: critique is part of kitchen culture—bigotry isn’t. Respect the craft, respect the culture, or step off the line.

---

🌱 Final Thoughts

Food is memory, technique, and history on a plate. Treating a whole cuisine like a punchline doesn’t make you elite—it makes you small.

Call things by their names, draw your lines, and keep cooking with pride. The right people will pull up a chair.

What do you think?
Would you have apologized to keep the peace, or held your ground like OP did? Share your thoughts below 👇

---